U sing a fan to keep yourself comfortable during a heatwave implies a series of strategies, as these devices do not have any real means to cool the air. At the opposite pole, an AC is the easiest solution, but the prices are high and their run can easily make your energy bill spike up.
Fortunately, a compromise solution exists. Misting fans and evaporative coolers are a combination of fans and ACs. They manage to bring coolness in the space they work while keeping the power consumption low. They do sound amazing. Nevertheless, we should mention from the start that these devices would work better in areas with dry climates, as their working method implies evaporation.
Now, if you were to pick between one of these technologies, you would need all the information you can get, and this is exactly what we have our mind set on: we will compare all the aspects regarding these two coolers and underline their advantages and drawbacks, so stay with us for a complete analysis.
What Is the Technology Behind These Systems? Presenting the Candidates
Although they seem to do the same thing, namely use a fan and water to create the sensation of coolness on the skin, some differences do exist, and they are found in the way each system operates.
How Do Misting Fans Work?
The two main components of a mister are the fan and the pump. The unit requires to be connected both to an energy source and a water source. Usually, a garden hose can do the trick, making installation easier and maintenance almost inexistent. However, if this isn’t possible, it is good to know that you can pick a unit with a water bucket. Thus, the unit becomes more portable but sort of uncomfortable, as you will need to refill it, probably several times a day.
Once you’ve managed to get it installed, the process goes the following way: the pump draws the water and pressurizes it, turning it into droplets. The fan draws the hot air and mixes it with the fine cool mist, then blows it around the perimeter. During this action, three processes occur: the cool air reaches your skin and swipes away the heat (this is called convection), the water droplets transfer coolness to your skin, lowering the temperature (this is called conduction), and in its way to you, the mist manages to preserve its coolness as the droplets that get too warm turn to vapors before reaching your skin (this is called evaporation).
For garden or patio air cooling, see our outdoor misting fan selection. Analyze complete specs and features and compare prices, to find the best model for your summer parties.
Benefits & Drawbacks
Misting units are highly popular, despite the fact that they, just like any appliance, have their good and bad sides. Take a look at what they can do for you and assess if the drawbacks are of no importance or a deal-breaker for you:
How Do Evaporative (Swamp) Coolers Work?
Unlike misting models, swamp coolers do not require a pump and will not release any fine mist. They come with a water recipient, a fan, and a series of pads, and this is all they need to work their magic. The process goes this way: you fill the water recipient and turn on the unit. At this point, the pads will soak part of the water, becoming ready for the evaporation process. When the fan starts spinning, it draws the hot air inside the unit and makes it pass through the wet pads. As the air is hot, the water will begin to evaporate and make the air moister. The air charged with water vapors is blown back, reaching your skin and making you feel cooler.
More than misters, swamp coolers require to be used in environments with low humidity and high temperatures. They need the heat for the evaporation process to take place and they need the RH to be low, as evaporation cannot happen if the air is saturated with water. This is actually a good thing, and you will find it at evaporative humidifiers as well, because it means that over humidification can be easily avoided and the risk of mold growing on the walls dodged, but, in this case, this will also mean a pause in cooling and an inefficient run of the machine.
For excellent spot cooling, check out our portable evaporative air coolers. Some models come with filters and can guarantee that the vapors released will be free of contaminants.
Benefits & Drawbacks
Misting Fan vs. Swamp Cooler
It is only when we put them side by side and perform a thorough analysis of their performance according to various criteria, that these devices reveal their qualities and differences, allowing you to assess which technology could serve you best. So, let’s start from installation and go through the most important aspects, in an attempt to see what sets these units apart.
When it comes to installing a swamp model, you will only need to get it from the box, fill the reservoir with water, and plug it in. But this will happen only if you have purchased a portable model. For window units, things are a bit different, and you should take your time and prepare for some effort, as you will need to lift a pretty bulky unit at window level, ensure it using chains and hooks, cover the space around it so insects don’t invade the house, and only after all this work, fill the reservoir with water and enjoy the results.
Regarding misters, if the water source is at hand, then things couldn’t be easier. You just use a garden hose to get your unit linked to the water supply. But this is the best-case scenario. In the worst-case scenario, the water source is far from the location where you wish to place the unit and you will need to make arrangements to get the water to it. This can imply plumbing work and even the services of a professional. Plus, if your cooler doesn’t come with a pump and relies only on the local water pressure, a lot of this pressure will be lost on the way, so the cooling will be less effective.
If we are talking portability, then a misting fan is usually more effective than its counter candidate for the simple reason that it doesn’t need to wait for the water to evaporate to provide coolness. Nevertheless, a window swamp model is the best you can get for complete room cooling. These units can have airflows that reach over 7,000 CFM and get installed into the window, so they won’t come in your way. The alternative may prove too space-consuming for a small room.
Take a look at our best vertical window ACs and find a method to clear floor space and still keep one side of the window free. Although more expensive than fans, these ACs will cool a room in no time, while reducing humidity as well.
Although both options are cost-effective, one totally wins in this section. A swamp cooler will draw between 400 and 700 watts, which is still under the power consumption rate of a small AC. But when compared to a misting fan, which doesn’t consume more than 300 watts, the difference is impossible to be ignored.
They both require a certain quantity of water but, although they are known to recycle the non-used water, swamp units tend to swallow more. If a mister and a swamp unit of the same capacity are used at the same time and at the same speed level, the water in the evaporative unit’s reservoir will be the first to end.
If the water is a problem in your area, then you may want to think of other cooling methods. Check out our best dual hose portable ACs and get excellent coolness with no water consumption at all.
The single fact that evaporators require a reservoir to work makes them more difficult to maintain. This would imply daily maintenance, namely, you will need to fill the water recipient several times a day and make sure to dust the unit to keep as much dust as possible away from the blades. Periodical maintenance is the second part of the process, and this will consist of a thorough cleaning of the water recipient by using vinegar and a chlorine-based solution to disinfect it. A window unit will require professional cleaning for the best results. Plus, you will need to invest in water pads once or twice a year.
Misting units require almost no daily maintenance, assuming that they are connected to a water source. If they use a bucket, then the same process of filling it several times a day will be followed. The good news though is that you will not need to have a professional clean your unit. Every three months, you can find the time to open the head of the unit, clean the grilles, the blades, and the water nozzle, dry them properly and set them back together.
You can get a swamp unit for a lower price than a mister, but the installation costs can be considerable if you let a specialist do it, ranging from 700 dollars to the impressive sum of 2,000 dollars. If we consider that an evaporative unit costs between $100 and $600, it is easy to see that the installation can cost you more than the product. On the other hand, if you pick a portable unit, you can skip all these extra costs and start enjoying the benefits within minutes from the unit’s arrival.
Misting fans usually start at $400 and can reach a few thousand dollars. However, they don’t need to be installed and are known to be more durable than swamp units.
At the end of this analysis, here are some considerations that may help you decide.
You should pick a misting fan if:
- You wish to cool an outdoor area
- You are hoping for foggy effects – a special kit can offer you that
- You have a water source available in the right spot
- You are not willing to put up with complex installation
You should pick an evaporative cooler if:
- You are on a budget
- You have practical skills that allow you to perform the installation
- You need to cool an entire room and the space is limited – window models
- You need to cool an outdoor area – portable units
You shouldn’t buy any of these devices if you are living in an area where high humidity is a problem. The only thing you will want is a machine that can make it even harder for the sweat on your skin to evaporate. Plus, as we have explained, high levels of moisture mean high chances of mold and bacteria thriving in your house. In this case, you will need a unit that can dry the air. You can use either a tower fan to remove moisture by circulating the air, an air conditioner (all these units include dehumidification), or a proper dehumidifier, which is the most effective method.